clause.h

Go to the documentation of this file.

// Copyright 2010-2025 Google LLC
// Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
// you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
// You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
//     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.
 
// This file contains the solver internal representation of the clauses and the
// classes used for their propagation.
 
#ifndef ORTOOLS_SAT_CLAUSE_H_
#define ORTOOLS_SAT_CLAUSE_H_
 
#include <cstdint>
#include <deque>
#include <functional>
#include <optional>
#include <string>
#include <utility>
#include <vector>
 
#include "absl/base/attributes.h"
#include "absl/container/flat_hash_map.h"
#include "absl/container/flat_hash_set.h"
#include "absl/functional/any_invocable.h"
#include "absl/functional/function_ref.h"
#include "absl/log/check.h"
#include "absl/types/span.h"
#include "ortools/base/strong_vector.h"
#include "ortools/graph/cliques.h"
#include "ortools/sat/container.h"
#include "ortools/sat/lrat_proof_handler.h"
#include "ortools/sat/model.h"
#include "ortools/sat/sat_base.h"
#include "ortools/sat/sat_parameters.pb.h"
#include "ortools/sat/util.h"
#include "ortools/util/bitset.h"
#include "ortools/util/stats.h"
#include "ortools/util/strong_integers.h"
#include "ortools/util/time_limit.h"
 
namespace operations_research {
namespace sat {
 
// This is how the SatSolver stores a clause. A clause is just a disjunction of
// literals. In many places, we just use vector<literal> to encode one. But in
// the critical propagation code, we use this class to remove one memory
// indirection.
class SatClause {
 public:
  // Creates a sat clause. There must be at least 2 literals.
  // Clause with one literal fix variable directly and are never constructed.
  // Note that in practice, we use BinaryImplicationGraph for the clause of size
  // 2, so this is used for size at least 3.
  static SatClause* Create(absl::Span<const Literal> literals);
 
  // Non-sized delete because this is a tail-padded class.
  void operator delete(void* p) {
    ::operator delete(p);  // non-sized delete
  }
 
  // Number of literals in the clause.
  int size() const { return size_; }
  bool empty() const { return size_ == 0; }
 
  // We re-use the size to lazily remove clause and notify that they need to be
  // deleted. It is why this is not called empty() to emphasis that fact. Note
  // that we never create an initially empty clause, so there is no confusion
  // with an infeasible model with an empty clause inside.
  int IsRemoved() const { return size_ == 0; }
 
  // Allows for range based iteration: for (Literal literal : clause) {}.
  const Literal* begin() const { return &(literals_[0]); }
  const Literal* end() const { return &(literals_[size_]); }
 
  // Returns the first and second literals. These are always the watched
  // literals if the clause is attached in the LiteralWatchers.
  Literal FirstLiteral() const { return literals_[0]; }
  Literal SecondLiteral() const { return literals_[1]; }
 
  // Returns the literal that was propagated to true. This only works for a
  // clause that just propagated this literal. Otherwise, this will just returns
  // a literal of the clause.
  Literal PropagatedLiteral() const { return literals_[0]; }
 
  // Returns the reason for the last unit propagation of this clause. The
  // preconditions are the same as for PropagatedLiteral(). Note that we don't
  // need to include the propagated literal.
  absl::Span<const Literal> PropagationReason() const {
    return absl::Span<const Literal>(&(literals_[1]), size_ - 1);
  }
 
  // Returns a Span<> representation of the clause.
  absl::Span<const Literal> AsSpan() const {
    return absl::Span<const Literal>(&(literals_[0]), size_);
  }
 
  // Returns true if the clause is satisfied for the given assignment. Note that
  // the assignment may be partial, so false does not mean that the clause can't
  // be satisfied by completing the assignment.
  bool IsSatisfied(const VariablesAssignment& assignment) const;
 
  std::string DebugString() const;
 
 private:
  // The manager needs to permute the order of literals in the clause and
  // call Clear()/Rewrite.
  friend class ClauseManager;
 
  Literal* literals() { return &(literals_[0]); }
 
  // Marks the clause so that the next call to CleanUpWatchers() can identify it
  // and actually remove it. We use size_ = 0 for this since the clause will
  // never be used afterwards.
  void Clear() { size_ = 0; }
 
  // Removes literals that are fixed. This should only be called at level 0
  // where a literal is fixed iff it is assigned. Aborts and returns true if
  // they are not all false.
  //
  // Note that the removed literal can still be accessed in the portion [size,
  // old_size) of literals().
  bool RemoveFixedLiteralsAndTestIfTrue(const VariablesAssignment& assignment);
 
  // Rewrites a clause with another shorter one. Note that the clause shouldn't
  // be attached when this is called.
  void Rewrite(absl::Span<const Literal> new_clause) {
    size_ = 0;
    for (const Literal l : new_clause) literals_[size_++] = l;
  }
 
  int32_t size_;
 
  // This class store the literals inline, and literals_ mark the starts of the
  // variable length portion.
  Literal literals_[0];
};
 
// Clause information used for the clause database management. Note that only
// the clauses that can be removed have an info. The problem clauses and
// the learned one that we wants to keep forever do not have one.
struct ClauseInfo {
  double activity = 0.0;
  int32_t lbd = 0;
  int32_t num_cleanup_rounds_since_last_bumped = 0;
};
 
class BinaryImplicationGraph;
 
// Used for tracking the source of LazyDelete() for each clauses.
enum class DeletionSourceForStat {
  FIXED_AT_TRUE,
  CONTAINS_L_AND_NOT_L,
  PROMOTED_TO_BINARY,
  SUBSUMPTION_PROBING,
  SUBSUMPTION_VIVIFY,
  SUBSUMPTION_CONFLICT,
  SUBSUMPTION_CONFLICT_EXTRA,
  SUBSUMPTION_DECISIONS,
  SUBSUMPTION_EAGER,
  SUBSUMPTION_INPROCESSING,
  BLOCKED,
  ELIMINATED,
  GARBAGE_COLLECTED,
  LastElement,  // For resising.
};
 
// Stores the 2-watched literals data structure.  See
// http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~necula/autded/lecture24-sat.pdf for
// detail.
//
// This class is also responsible for owning the clause memory and all related
// information.
class ClauseManager : public SatPropagator {
 public:
  explicit ClauseManager(Model* model);
 
  // This type is neither copyable nor movable.
  ClauseManager(const ClauseManager&) = delete;
  ClauseManager& operator=(const ClauseManager&) = delete;
 
  ~ClauseManager() override;
 
  // Must be called before adding clauses referring to such variables.
  void Resize(int num_variables);
 
  // SatPropagator API.
  bool Propagate(Trail* trail) final;
  absl::Span<const Literal> Reason(const Trail& trail, int trail_index,
                                   int64_t conflict_id) const final;
  void Reimply(Trail* trail, int old_trail_index) final;
 
  // Returns the reason of the variable at given trail_index. This only works
  // for variable propagated by this class and is almost the same as Reason()
  // with a different return format.
  SatClause* ReasonClause(int trail_index) const;
 
  // Returns the clause that fixed `var`, or nullptr if `var` is not fixed, or
  // was not fixed by a clause.
  SatClause* ReasonClauseOrNull(BooleanVariable var) const;
 
  // Returns true iff the clause is the reason for an assigned variable.
  bool ClauseIsUsedAsReason(SatClause* clause) const;
 
  // Adds a new clause and perform initial propagation for this clause only.
  bool AddClause(ClauseId id, absl::Span<const Literal> literals, Trail* trail,
                 int lbd);
  bool AddClause(absl::Span<const Literal> literals);
 
  // Same as AddClause() for a removable clause. This is only called on learned
  // conflict, so this should never have all its literal at false (CHECKED).
  SatClause* AddRemovableClause(ClauseId id, absl::Span<const Literal> literals,
                                Trail* trail, int lbd);
 
  // Returns the number of deletion for each DeletionSourceForStat type.
  absl::Span<const int64_t> DeletionCounters() const {
    return deletion_counters_;
  }
 
  // Lazily detach the given clause. Watchers are removed during propagation or
  // when CleanUpWatchers() is called, and the clause will be deleted by
  // DeleteRemovedClauses().
  //
  // Note that we remove the clause from clauses_info_ right away.
  // Callers must not reattach `clause` after calling this method.
  void LazyDelete(SatClause* clause, DeletionSourceForStat source);
 
  // Removes all watchers for any clauses that have been lazily detached.
  void CleanUpWatchers();
 
  // Attaches the given clause. The first two literal of the clause must
  // be unassigned and the clause must not be already attached.
  void Attach(SatClause* clause, Trail* trail);
 
  // Reclaims the memory of the lazily removed clauses (their size was set to
  // zero) and remove them from AllClausesInCreationOrder() this work in
  // O(num_clauses()).
  void DeleteRemovedClauses();
  int64_t num_clauses() const { return clauses_.size(); }
  const std::vector<SatClause*>& AllClausesInCreationOrder() const {
    return clauses_;
  }
 
  // True if removing this clause will not change the set of feasible solution.
  // This is the case for clauses that were learned during search. Note however
  // that some learned clause are kept forever (heuristics) and do not appear
  // here.
  bool IsRemovable(SatClause* const clause) const {
    return clauses_info_.contains(clause);
  }
  int64_t num_removable_clauses() const { return clauses_info_.size(); }
  absl::flat_hash_map<SatClause*, ClauseInfo>* mutable_clauses_info() {
    return &clauses_info_;
  }
  int LbdOrZeroIfNotRemovable(SatClause* const clause) const {
    auto it = clauses_info_.find(clause);
    if (it == clauses_info_.end()) return 0;
    return it->second.lbd;
  }
  void KeepClauseForever(SatClause* const clause) {
    clauses_info_.erase(clause);
  }
  void RescaleClauseActivities(double scaling_factor) {
    for (auto& entry : clauses_info_) {
      entry.second.activity *= scaling_factor;
    }
  }
 
  // If the new lbd is better than the stored one, update it.
  // And return the result of IsRemovable() (this save one hash lookup).
  void ChangeLbdIfBetter(SatClause* clause, int new_lbd);
 
  // Total number of clauses inspected during calls to Propagate().
  int64_t num_inspected_clauses() const { return num_inspected_clauses_; }
  int64_t num_inspected_clause_literals() const {
    return num_inspected_clause_literals_;
  }
 
  // The number of different literals (always twice the number of variables).
  int64_t literal_size() const { return needs_cleaning_.size().value(); }
 
  // Number of clauses currently watched.
  int64_t num_watched_clauses() const { return num_watched_clauses_; }
 
  // Number of time an existing clause lbd was reduced (due to inprocessing or
  // recomputation of lbd in different branches).
  int64_t num_lbd_promotions() const { return num_lbd_promotions_; }
 
  ClauseId GetClauseId(const SatClause* clause) const {
    const auto it = clause_id_.find(clause);
    return it != clause_id_.end() ? it->second : kNoClauseId;
  }
 
  void SetClauseId(const SatClause* clause, ClauseId id) {
    clause_id_[clause] = id;
  }
 
  // Methods implementing pseudo-iterators over the clause database that are
  // stable across cleanups. They all return nullptr if there are no more
  // clauses.
 
  // Returns the next clause to minimize that has never been minimized before.
  // Note that we only minimize clauses kept forever.
  SatClause* NextNewClauseToMinimize();
 
  // Returns the next clause to minimize, this iterator will be reset to the
  // start so the clauses will be returned in round-robin order.
  // Note that we only minimize clauses kept forever.
  SatClause* NextClauseToMinimize();
 
  // Returns the next clause to probe in round-robin order.
  SatClause* NextClauseToProbe();
 
  // This is used for the "eager" subsumption. Each time we learn a conflict, we
  // see if one of the last learned clause can be subsumed with it or not.
  absl::Span<SatClause*> LastNClauses(int n) {
    if (n > clauses_.size()) n = clauses_.size();
    return absl::MakeSpan(clauses_).subspan(clauses_.size() - n);
  }
 
  // Restart the scans.
  void ResetToProbeIndex() { to_probe_index_ = 0; }
  int64_t NumToMinimizeIndexResets() const {
    return num_to_minimize_index_resets_;
  }
 
  // Ensures that NextNewClauseToMinimize() returns only learned clauses.
  // This is a noop after the first call.
  void EnsureNewClauseIndexInitialized() {
    if (to_first_minimize_index_ > 0) return;
    to_first_minimize_index_ = clauses_.size();
  }
 
  // During an inprocessing phase, it is easier to detach all clause first,
  // then simplify and then reattach them. Note however that during these
  // two calls, it is not possible to use the solver unit-progation.
  //
  // Important: When reattach is called, we assume that none of their literal
  // are fixed, so we don't do any special checks.
  //
  // These functions can be called multiple-time and do the right things. This
  // way before doing something, you can call the corresponding function and be
  // sure to be in a good state. I.e. always AttachAllClauses() before
  // propagation and DetachAllClauses() before going to do an inprocessing pass
  // that might transform them.
  void DetachAllClauses();
  void AttachAllClauses();
 
  // Replaces a clause with a subset of the literals.
  // This may be called while clauses are attached, but the first two literals
  // in new_clause must be valid watchers.
  // This does *not* propagate the clause.
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool InprocessingRewriteClause(
      SatClause* clause, absl::Span<const Literal> new_clause,
      absl::Span<const ClauseId> clause_ids = {});
 
  bool RemoveFixedLiteralsAndTestIfTrue(SatClause* clause);
 
  // Fix a literal either with an existing LRAT `unit_clause_id`, or with a new
  // inferred unit clause, using `clause_ids` as proof.
  // This do NOT need to be between [Detach/Attach]AllClauses() calls.
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool InprocessingAddUnitClause(ClauseId unit_clause_id,
                                                      Literal true_literal);
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool InprocessingFixLiteral(
      Literal true_literal, absl::Span<const ClauseId> clause_ids = {});
 
  // This can return nullptr if new_clause was of size one or two as these are
  // treated differently. Note that none of the variable should be fixed in the
  // given new clause.
  SatClause* InprocessingAddClause(absl::Span<const Literal> new_clause);
 
  // Contains, for each literal, the list of clauses that need to be inspected
  // when the corresponding literal becomes false.
  struct Watcher {
    Watcher() = default;
    Watcher(SatClause* c, Literal b, int i = 2)
        : blocking_literal(b), start_index(i), clause(c) {}
 
    // Optimization. A literal from the clause that sometimes allow to not even
    // look at the clause memory when true.
    Literal blocking_literal;
 
    // Optimization. An index in the clause. Instead of looking for another
    // literal to watch from the start, we will start from here instead, and
    // loop around if needed. This allows to avoid bad quadratic corner cases
    // and lead to an "optimal" complexity. See "Optimal Implementation of
    // Watched Literals and more General Techniques", Ian P. Gent.
    //
    // Note that ideally, this should be part of a SatClause, so it can be
    // shared across watchers. However, since we have 32 bits for "free" here
    // because of the struct alignment, we store it here instead.
    int32_t start_index;
 
    SatClause* clause;
  };
 
  // This is exposed since some inprocessing code can heuristically exploit the
  // currently watched literal and blocking literal to do some simplification.
  const std::vector<Watcher>& WatcherListOnFalse(Literal false_literal) const {
    return watchers_on_false_[false_literal];
  }
 
  void SetAddClauseCallback(
      absl::AnyInvocable<void(int lbd, ClauseId id, absl::Span<const Literal>)>
          add_clause_callback) {
    add_clause_callback_ = std::move(add_clause_callback);
  }
 
  // Removes the add clause callback and returns it. This can be used to
  // temporarily disable the callback.
  absl::AnyInvocable<void(int lbd, ClauseId id, absl::Span<const Literal>)>
  TakeAddClauseCallback() {
    return std::move(add_clause_callback_);
  }
 
  // Returns the ID of the unit, binary, or general clause that is the reason
  // for the given literal, or kNoClauseId if there is none.
  ClauseId ReasonClauseId(Literal literal) const;
 
  // Appends to `clause_ids` the IDs of the clauses which, by unit propagation
  // from some decisions, are sufficient to ensure that all literals in
  // `literals` are fixed to their current value.
  //
  // If `decision` is not `kNoLiteralIndex`, also appends the IDs of the clauses
  // proving that `decision` implies all the literals in `literals`. In this
  // case, `decision` must either be the last decision on the trail, or must
  // directly imply it. Furthermore, each decision must directly imply the
  // previous one on the trail.
  //
  // This method expands the reasons of each literal recursively until a
  // decision, or a literal implied by the decision at its decision level, or a
  // literal for which `root_literals` returns a value other than kNoClauseId,
  // is found. The latter criteria avoid a quadratic complexity when
  // implications of the form "decision(s) => literal" are added for each newly
  // propagated literal after taking a decision (provided these implications are
  // added to the binary implication graph or to the `root_literals` function
  // right away, in trail index order).
  //
  // `root_literals` must take a decision level and a trail index as parameter
  // (the level is the assignment level of this trail index). It must return the
  // ID of the clause stating that the literal at this index is fixed by
  // previous decision(s), if the reason expansion should be stopped here
  // (otherwise it should return kNoClauseId).
  void AppendClauseIdsFixing(
      absl::Span<const Literal> literals, std::vector<ClauseId>* clause_ids,
      LiteralIndex decision = kNoLiteralIndex,
      std::optional<absl::FunctionRef<ClauseId(int, int)>> root_literals = {});
 
 private:
  // Attaches the given clause. This eventually propagates a literal which is
  // enqueued on the trail. Returns false if a contradiction was encountered.
  bool AttachAndPropagate(SatClause* clause, Trail* trail);
 
  // Attaches the given clause to the event: the given literal becomes false.
  // The blocking_literal can be any literal from the clause, it is used to
  // speed up Propagate() by skipping the clause if it is true.
  void AttachOnFalse(Literal literal, Literal blocking_literal,
                     SatClause* clause);
 
  // Common code between LazyDelete() and Detach().
  void InternalDetach(SatClause* clause, DeletionSourceForStat source);
 
  ClauseIdGenerator* clause_id_generator_;
 
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, std::vector<Watcher>>
      watchers_on_false_;
 
  // SatClause reasons by trail_index.
  std::vector<SatClause*> reasons_;
 
  // Indicates if the corresponding watchers_on_false_ list need to be
  // cleaned. The boolean is_clean_ is just used in DCHECKs.
  SparseBitset<LiteralIndex> needs_cleaning_;
  bool is_clean_ = true;
 
  const SatParameters& parameters_;
  const VariablesAssignment& assignment_;
  BinaryImplicationGraph* implication_graph_;
  Trail* trail_;
 
  // For statistic reporting.
  std::vector<int64_t> deletion_counters_;
  int64_t num_inspected_clauses_ = 0;
  int64_t num_inspected_clause_literals_ = 0;
  int64_t num_watched_clauses_ = 0;
  int64_t num_lbd_promotions_ = 0;
  mutable StatsGroup stats_;
 
  // For DetachAllClauses()/AttachAllClauses().
  bool all_clauses_are_attached_ = true;
 
  // All the clauses currently in memory. This vector has ownership of the
  // pointers. We currently do not use std::unique_ptr<SatClause> because it
  // can't be used with some STL algorithms like std::partition.
  //
  // Note that the unit clauses and binary clause are not kept here.
  std::vector<SatClause*> clauses_;
 
  // TODO(user): If more indices are needed, switch to a generic API.
  int to_minimize_index_ = 0;
 
  int num_to_minimize_index_resets_ = 0;
  int to_first_minimize_index_ = 0;
  int to_probe_index_ = 0;
 
  absl::flat_hash_map<const SatClause*, ClauseId> clause_id_;
  // Only contains removable clause.
  absl::flat_hash_map<SatClause*, ClauseInfo> clauses_info_;
 
  LratProofHandler* lrat_proof_handler_ = nullptr;
 
  // Temporary member used when adding LRAT inferred clauses.
  std::vector<ClauseId> clause_ids_scratchpad_;
 
  absl::AnyInvocable<void(int lbd, ClauseId id, absl::Span<const Literal>)>
      add_clause_callback_ = nullptr;
 
  SparseBitset<BooleanVariable> tmp_mark_;
  std::vector<int> marked_trail_indices_heap_;
  std::vector<ClauseId> tmp_clause_ids_for_append_clauses_fixing_;
};
 
// A binary clause. This is used by BinaryClauseManager.
struct BinaryClause {
  BinaryClause(Literal _a, Literal _b) : id(-1), a(_a), b(_b) {}
  bool operator==(BinaryClause o) const { return a == o.a && b == o.b; }
  bool operator!=(BinaryClause o) const { return a != o.a || b != o.b; }
  ClauseId id;
  Literal a;
  Literal b;
};
 
// A simple class to manage a set of binary clauses.
class BinaryClauseManager {
 public:
  BinaryClauseManager() = default;
 
  // This type is neither copyable nor movable.
  BinaryClauseManager(const BinaryClauseManager&) = delete;
  BinaryClauseManager& operator=(const BinaryClauseManager&) = delete;
 
  int NumClauses() const { return set_.size(); }
 
  // Adds a new binary clause to the manager and returns true if it wasn't
  // already present.
  bool Add(BinaryClause c) {
    std::pair<int, int> p(c.a.SignedValue(), c.b.SignedValue());
    if (p.first > p.second) std::swap(p.first, p.second);
    if (set_.find(p) == set_.end()) {
      set_.insert(p);
      newly_added_.push_back(c);
      return true;
    }
    return false;
  }
 
  // Returns the newly added BinaryClause since the last ClearNewlyAdded() call.
  const std::vector<BinaryClause>& newly_added() const { return newly_added_; }
  void ClearNewlyAdded() { newly_added_.clear(); }
 
 private:
  absl::flat_hash_set<std::pair<int, int>> set_;
  std::vector<BinaryClause> newly_added_;
};
 
// Internal BinaryImplicationGraph helper for LRAT in DetectEquivalences().
class LratEquivalenceHelper;
 
// Special class to store and propagate clauses of size 2 (i.e. implication).
// Such clauses are never deleted. Together, they represent the 2-SAT part of
// the problem. Note that 2-SAT satisfiability is a polynomial problem, but
// W2SAT (weighted 2-SAT) is NP-complete.
//
// TODO(user): Most of the note below are done, but we currently only applies
// the reduction before the solve. We should consider doing more in-processing.
// The code could probably still be improved too.
//
// Note(user): All the variables in a strongly connected component are
// equivalent and can be thus merged as one. This is relatively cheap to compute
// from time to time (linear complexity). We will also get contradiction (a <=>
// not a) this way. This is done by DetectEquivalences().
//
// Note(user): An implication (a => not a) implies that a is false. I am not
// sure it is worth detecting that because if the solver assign a to true, it
// will learn that right away. I don't think we can do it faster.
//
// Note(user): The implication graph can be pruned. This is called the
// transitive reduction of a graph. For instance If a => {b,c} and b => {c},
// then there is no need to store a => {c}. The transitive reduction is unique
// on an acyclic graph. Computing it will allow for a faster propagation and
// memory reduction. It is however not cheap. Maybe simple lazy heuristics to
// remove redundant arcs are better. Note that all the learned clauses we add
// will never be redundant (but they could introduce cycles). This is done
// by ComputeTransitiveReduction().
//
// Note(user): This class natively support at most one constraints. This is
// a way to reduced significantly the memory and size of some 2-SAT instances.
// However, it is not fully exploited for pure SAT problems. See
// TransformIntoMaxCliques().
//
// Note(user): Add a preprocessor to remove duplicates in the implication lists.
// Note that all the learned clauses we add will never create duplicates.
//
// References for most of the above and more:
// - Brafman RI, "A simplifier for propositional formulas with many binary
//   clauses", IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern B Cybern. 2004 Feb;34(1):52-9.
//   http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.28.4911
// - Marijn J. H. Heule, Matti Järvisalo, Armin Biere, "Efficient CNF
//   Simplification Based on Binary Implication Graphs", Theory and Applications
//   of Satisfiability Testing - SAT 2011, Lecture Notes in Computer Science
//   Volume 6695, 2011, pp 201-215
//   http://www.cs.helsinki.fi/u/mjarvisa/papers/heule-jarvisalo-biere.sat11.pdf
class BinaryImplicationGraph : public SatPropagator {
 public:
  explicit BinaryImplicationGraph(Model* model);
 
  // This type is neither copyable nor movable.
  BinaryImplicationGraph(const BinaryImplicationGraph&) = delete;
  BinaryImplicationGraph& operator=(const BinaryImplicationGraph&) = delete;
 
  ~BinaryImplicationGraph() override;
 
  // SatPropagator interface.
  bool Propagate(Trail* trail) final;
  absl::Span<const Literal> Reason(const Trail& trail, int trail_index,
                                   int64_t conflict_id) const final;
  void Reimply(Trail* trail, int old_trail_index) final;
 
  // Resizes the data structure.
  void Resize(int num_variables);
 
  // Returns the "size" of this class, that is 2 * num_boolean_variables as
  // updated by the larger Resize() call.
  int64_t literal_size() const { return implications_and_amos_.size(); }
 
  // Returns true if no constraints where ever added to this class.
  bool IsEmpty() const final { return no_constraint_ever_added_; }
 
  // Adds the binary clause (a OR b), which is the same as (not a => b).
  // Note that it is also equivalent to (not b => a). More precisely, adds the
  // binary clause (rep(a) OR rep(b)), where rep(l) is the representative of l.
  // If they are different from a and b, a new inferred LRAT clause is also
  // added (if an LRAT proof handler is set), with a new clause ID (and the old
  // LRAT `id` clause is deleted, unless `delete_non_representative_id` is
  // false).
  //
  // Preconditions:
  // - If we are at root node, then none of the literal should be assigned.
  //   This is Checked and is there to track inefficiency as we do not need a
  //   clause in this case.
  // - If we are at a positive decision level, we will propagate something if
  //   we can. However, if both literal are false, we will just return false
  //   and do nothing. In all other case, we will return true.
  bool AddBinaryClause(ClauseId id, Literal a, Literal b,
                       bool delete_non_representative_id = true) {
    return AddBinaryClauseInternal(id, a, b, /*change_reason=*/false,
                                   delete_non_representative_id);
  }
  bool AddBinaryClause(Literal a, Literal b) {
    return AddBinaryClause(kNoClauseId, a, b);
  }
  bool AddImplication(Literal a, Literal b) {
    return AddBinaryClause(a.Negated(), b);
  }
 
  ClauseId GetClauseId(Literal a, Literal b) const {
    if (a.Variable() > b.Variable()) std::swap(a, b);
    const auto it = clause_id_.find(std::make_pair(a, b));
    return it != clause_id_.end() ? it->second : kNoClauseId;
  }
 
  // When set, the callback will be called on ALL newly added binary clauses.
  //
  // The EnableSharing() function can be used to disable sharing temporarily for
  // the clauses that are imported from the Shared repository already.
  //
  // TODO(user): this is meant to share clause between workers, hopefully the
  // contention will not be too high. Double check and maybe add a batch version
  // were we keep new implication and add them in batches.
  void EnableSharing(bool enable) { enable_sharing_ = enable; }
  void SetAdditionCallback(std::function<void(Literal, Literal)> f) {
    add_binary_callback_ = f;
  }
  // An at most one constraint of size n is a compact way to encode n * (n - 1)
  // implications. This must only be called at level zero.
  //
  // Returns false if this creates a conflict. Currently this can only happens
  // if there is duplicate literal already assigned to true in this constraint.
  //
  // TODO(user): Our algorithm could generalize easily to at_most_ones + a list
  // of literals that will be false if one of the literal in the amo is at one.
  // It is a way to merge common list of implications.
  //
  // If the final AMO size is smaller than at_most_one_expansion_size
  // parameters, we fully expand it.
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool AddAtMostOne(absl::Span<const Literal> at_most_one);
 
  // Uses the binary implication graph to minimize the given conflict by
  // removing literals that implies others. The idea is that if a and b are two
  // literals from the given conflict and a => b (which is the same as not(b) =>
  // not(a)) then a is redundant and can be removed. If an LRAT proof handler is
  // set, fills the LRAT proof for these implications in `clause_ids`.
  //
  // Note that removing as many literals as possible is too time consuming, so
  // we use different heuristics/algorithms to do this minimization.
  // See the binary_minimization_algorithm SAT parameter and the .cc for more
  // details about the different algorithms.
  void MinimizeConflictFirst(const Trail& trail, std::vector<Literal>* c,
                             SparseBitset<BooleanVariable>* marked,
                             std::vector<ClauseId>* clause_ids,
                             bool also_use_decisions);
 
  // Appends the IDs of the unit and binary clauses that imply the given
  // literals to `clause_ids`. Either `MinimizeConflictFirst` or
  // `ClearImpliedLiterals` must have been called just before, and the given
  // literals must be the reason of a literal in the conflict. Does nothing for
  // literals that have already been processed by a previous call to this
  // method.
  void AppendImplicationChains(absl::Span<const Literal> literals,
                               std::vector<ClauseId>* clause_ids);
 
  // This must only be called at decision level 0 after all the possible
  // propagations. It:
  // - Removes the variable at true from the implications lists.
  // - Frees the propagation list of the assigned literals.
  void RemoveFixedVariables();
 
  // Returns false if the model is unsat, otherwise detects equivalent variable
  // (with respect to the implications only) and reorganize the propagation
  // lists accordingly.
  //
  // TODO(user): Completely get rid of such literal instead? it might not be
  // reasonable code-wise to remap our literals in all of our constraints
  // though.
  bool DetectEquivalences(bool log_info = false);
 
  // Returns true if DetectEquivalences() has been called and no new binary
  // clauses have been added since then. When this is true then there is no
  // cycle in the binary implication graph (modulo the redundant literals that
  // form a cycle with their representative).
  bool IsDag() const { return is_dag_; }
 
  // One must call DetectEquivalences() first, this is CHECKed.
  // Returns a list so that if x => y, then x is after y.
  const std::vector<LiteralIndex>& ReverseTopologicalOrder() const {
    CHECK(is_dag_);
    return reverse_topological_order_;
  }
 
  // Returns the list of literal "directly" implied by l. Beware that this can
  // easily change behind your back if you modify the solver state.
  absl::Span<const Literal> Implications(Literal l) const {
    return implications_and_amos_[l].literals();
  }
 
  // Returns the representative of the equivalence class of l (or l itself if it
  // is on its own). Note that DetectEquivalences() should have been called to
  // get any non-trivial results.
  Literal RepresentativeOf(Literal l) const {
    if (l.Index() >= representative_of_.size()) return l;
    if (representative_of_[l] == kNoLiteralIndex) return l;
    return Literal(representative_of_[l]);
  }
 
  // Prunes the implication graph by calling first DetectEquivalences() to
  // remove cycle and then by computing the transitive reduction of the
  // remaining DAG.
  //
  // Note that this can be slow (num_literals graph traversals), so we abort
  // early if we start doing too much work.
  //
  // Returns false if the model is detected to be UNSAT (this needs to call
  // DetectEquivalences() if not already done).
  bool ComputeTransitiveReduction(bool log_info = false);
 
  // Another way of representing an implication graph is a list of maximal "at
  // most one" constraints, each forming a max-clique in the incompatibility
  // graph. This representation is useful for having a good linear relaxation.
  //
  // This function will transform each of the given constraint into a maximal
  // one in the underlying implication graph. Constraints that are redundant
  // after other have been expanded (i.e. included into) will be cleared.
  // Note that the order of constraints will be conserved.
  //
  // Returns false if the model is detected to be UNSAT (this needs to call
  // DetectEquivalences() if not already done).
  bool TransformIntoMaxCliques(std::vector<std::vector<Literal>>* at_most_ones,
                               int64_t max_num_explored_nodes = 1e8);
 
  // This is similar to TransformIntoMaxCliques() but we are just looking into
  // reducing the number of constraints. If two initial clique A and B can be
  // merged into A U B, we do it. We do not extends clique further.
  //
  // This approach should minimize the number of overall literals. It should
  // be also enough for presolve. We can extend clique even more later for
  // faster propagation or better linear relaxation.
  //
  // Note that we can do that relatively efficiently, if the candidate for
  // extension of a clique A contains clique B, then we can just extend.
  // Moreover this is a symmetric relation. And if we look at the graph of
  // possible extension (A <-> B if A U B is a valid clique), then we can
  // find maximum clique in this graph which might be relatively small.
  //
  // TODO(user): Switch to a dtime limit.
  bool MergeAtMostOnes(absl::Span<std::vector<Literal>> at_most_ones,
                       int64_t max_num_explored_nodes = 1e8,
                       double* dtime = nullptr);
 
  // LP clique cut heuristic. Returns a set of "at most one" constraints on the
  // given literals or their negation that are violated by the current LP
  // solution. Note that this assumes that
  //   lp_value(lit) = 1 - lp_value(lit.Negated()).
  //
  // The literal and lp_values vector are in one to one correspondence. We will
  // only generate clique with these literals or their negation.
  //
  // TODO(user): Refine the heuristic and unit test!
  const std::vector<std::vector<Literal>>& GenerateAtMostOnesWithLargeWeight(
      absl::Span<const Literal> literals, absl::Span<const double> lp_values,
      absl::Span<const double> reduced_costs);
 
  // Heuristically identify "at most one" between the given literals, swap
  // them around and return these amo as span inside the literals vector.
  //
  // TODO(user): Add a limit to make sure this do not take too much time.
  std::vector<absl::Span<const Literal>> HeuristicAmoPartition(
      std::vector<Literal>* literals);
 
  // Number of literal propagated by this class (including conflicts).
  int64_t num_propagations() const { return num_propagations_; }
 
  // Number of literals inspected by this class during propagation.
  int64_t num_inspections() const { return num_inspections_; }
 
  // MinimizeClause() stats.
  int64_t num_minimization() const { return num_minimization_; }
  int64_t num_literals_removed() const { return num_literals_removed_; }
 
  // Returns true if this literal is fixed or is equivalent to another literal.
  // This means that it can just be ignored in most situation.
  //
  // Note that the set (and thus number) of redundant literal can only grow over
  // time. This is because we always use the lowest index as representative of
  // an equivalent class, so a redundant literal will stay that way.
  bool IsRedundant(Literal l) const { return is_redundant_[l]; }
  int64_t num_redundant_literals() const {
    CHECK_EQ(num_redundant_literals_ % 2, 0);
    return num_redundant_literals_;
  }
 
  // Contrary to "num_redundant_literals_" this does not count equivalences for
  // fixed variables or variables that where deleted.
  int64_t num_current_equivalences() const {
    CHECK_EQ(num_current_equivalences_ % 2, 0);
    return num_current_equivalences_;
  }
 
  // Number of implications removed by transitive reduction.
  int64_t num_redundant_implications() const {
    return num_redundant_implications_;
  }
 
  // Returns the number of current implications. Note that a => b and not(b)
  // => not(a) are counted separately since they appear separately in our
  // propagation lists. The number of size 2 clauses that represent the same
  // thing is half this number. This should only be used in logs.
  int64_t ComputeNumImplicationsForLog() const {
    int64_t result = 0;
    for (const auto& list : implications_and_amos_) {
      result += list.num_literals();
    }
    return result;
  }
 
  // Extract all the binary clauses managed by this class. The Output type must
  // support an AddBinaryClause(Literal a, Literal b) function.
  //
  // Important: This currently does NOT include at most one constraints.
  //
  // TODO(user): When extracting to cp_model.proto we could be more efficient
  // by extracting bool_and constraint with many lhs terms.
  template <typename Output>
  void ExtractAllBinaryClauses(Output* out) const {
    // TODO(user): Ideally we should just never have duplicate clauses in this
    // class. But it seems we do in some corner cases, so lets not output them
    // twice.
    absl::flat_hash_set<std::pair<LiteralIndex, LiteralIndex>>
        duplicate_detection;
    for (LiteralIndex i(0); i < implications_and_amos_.size(); ++i) {
      const Literal a = Literal(i).Negated();
      for (const Literal b : implications_and_amos_[i].literals()) {
        // Note(user): We almost always have both a => b and not(b) => not(a) in
        // our implications_ database. Except if ComputeTransitiveReduction()
        // was aborted early, but in this case, if only one is present, the
        // other could be removed, so we shouldn't need to output it.
        if (a < b && duplicate_detection.insert({a, b}).second) {
          out->AddBinaryClause(a, b);
        }
      }
    }
  }
 
  // Adds a binary clause and changes the reason of `a` as if it were propagated
  // by this new clause.
  // This allows inprocessing to shrink clauses to binary without backtracking
  // to the root.
  bool AddBinaryClauseAndChangeReason(ClauseId id, Literal a, Literal b) {
    return AddBinaryClauseInternal(id, a, b, /*change_reason=*/true);
  }
 
  // The literals that are "directly" implied when literal is set to true. This
  // is not a full "reachability". It includes at most ones propagation. The set
  // of all direct implications is enough to describe the implications graph
  // completely.
  //
  // When doing blocked clause elimination of bounded variable elimination, one
  // only need to consider this list and not the full reachability.
  const std::vector<Literal>& DirectImplications(Literal literal);
 
  // Returns a random literal in DirectImplications(lhs). Note that this is
  // biased if lhs appear in some most one, but it is constant time, which is a
  // lot faster than computing DirectImplications() and then sampling from it.
  LiteralIndex RandomImpliedLiteral(Literal lhs);
 
  // A proxy for DirectImplications().size(), However we currently do not
  // maintain it perfectly. It is exact each time DirectImplications() is
  // called, and we update it in some situation but we don't deal with fixed
  // variables, at_most ones and duplicates implications for now.
  int DirectImplicationsEstimatedSize(Literal literal) const {
    return estimated_sizes_[literal];
  }
 
  // Variable elimination by replacing everything of the form a => var => b by
  // a => b. We ignore any a => a so the number of new implications is not
  // always just the product of the two direct implication list of var and
  // not(var). However, if a => var => a, then a and var are equivalent, so this
  // case will be removed if one run DetectEquivalences() before this.
  // Similarly, if a => var => not(a) then a must be false and this is detected
  // and dealt with by FindFailedLiteralAroundVar().
  bool FindFailedLiteralAroundVar(BooleanVariable var, bool* is_unsat);
  int64_t NumImplicationOnVariableRemoval(BooleanVariable var);
  void RemoveBooleanVariable(
      BooleanVariable var, std::deque<std::vector<Literal>>* postsolve_clauses);
  bool IsRemoved(Literal l) const { return is_removed_[l]; }
  void RemoveAllRedundantVariables(
      std::deque<std::vector<Literal>>* postsolve_clauses);
  void CleanupAllRemovedAndFixedVariables();
 
  // ExpandAtMostOneWithWeight() will increase this, so a client can put a limit
  // on this possibly expansive operation.
  void ResetWorkDone() { work_done_in_mark_descendants_ = 0; }
  int64_t WorkDone() const { return work_done_in_mark_descendants_; }
 
  // Returns all the literals that are implied directly or indirectly by `root`.
  // The result must be used before the next call to this function.
  // It is also possible to use LiteralIsImplied() to find in O(1) if one
  // literal is in the list.
  absl::Span<const Literal> GetAllImpliedLiterals(Literal root);
  bool LiteralIsImplied(Literal l) const { return is_marked_[l]; }
  void ClearImpliedLiterals();
 
  // Same as ExpandAtMostOne() but try to maximize the weight in the clique.
  template <bool use_weight = true>
  std::vector<Literal> ExpandAtMostOneWithWeight(
      absl::Span<const Literal> at_most_one,
      const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool>& can_be_included,
      const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, double>&
          expanded_lp_values);
 
  // Restarts the at_most_one iterator.
  void ResetAtMostOneIterator() { at_most_one_iterator_ = 0; }
 
  // Returns the next at_most_one, or a span of size 0 when finished.
  absl::Span<const Literal> NextAtMostOne();
 
  // Cleans up implications lists that might have duplicates.
  // This only touches lists that changed, so it is okay to call proactively.
  //
  // If we have l => x and not(x), this will also set l to false which might
  // casacade to an INFEASIBLE status in which case we will return false.
  bool RemoveDuplicatesAndFixedVariables();
 
  // For DCHECK() to debug inefficiency.
  bool HasNoDuplicates();
 
  // Returns an at most one "index" for all the at_most_ones containing this
  // literal. Warning: the indices are not necessarily super dense. This can be
  // used to detect that two literals are in the same AMO (i.e. if they share
  // the same index).
  absl::Span<const int> AtMostOneIndices(Literal lit) const {
    return implications_and_amos_[lit].offsets();
  }
 
  // Simple wrapper to not forget to output newly fixed variable to the DRAT
  // or LRAT proof (with clause_ids as proof) if needed. This will propagate
  // right away the implications.
  bool FixLiteral(Literal true_literal,
                  absl::Span<const ClauseId> clause_ids = {});
 
 private:
  friend class LratEquivalenceHelper;
 
  bool AddBinaryClauseInternal(ClauseId id, Literal a, Literal b,
                               bool change_reason = false,
                               bool delete_non_representative_id = true);
 
  // Marks implications_[a] for cleanup in RemoveDuplicatesAndFixedVariables().
  void NotifyPossibleDuplicate(Literal a);
 
  // Sorts, removes duplicates and detects l => x and not(x).
  // This only looks at the "direct" implications.
  // Returns false on UNSAT.
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool CleanUpImplicationList(Literal a);
 
  void AddClauseId(ClauseId id, Literal a, Literal b) {
    if (a.Variable() > b.Variable()) std::swap(a, b);
    clause_id_[{a, b}] = id;
  }
 
  // Removes any literal whose negation is marked (except the first one). If
  // `fill_clause_ids` is true, fills the LRAT proof for this change in
  // `clause_ids` (this requires an LRAT proof handler to be set, and
  // `implied_by_` to be up to date).
  template <bool fill_clause_ids = false>
  void RemoveRedundantLiterals(std::vector<Literal>* conflict,
                               std::vector<ClauseId>* clause_ids = nullptr);
 
  // Appends the IDs of the binary clauses that imply the given literal to
  // `clause_ids`.
  void AppendImplicationChain(Literal literal,
                              std::vector<ClauseId>* clause_ids);
 
  // Fills is_marked_ with all the descendant of root, and returns them. If
  // `fill_implied_by` is true, also stores the parent of each marked literal in
  // the implied_by_ array. Note that this also uses bfs_stack_.
  template <bool fill_implied_by = false>
  absl::Span<const Literal> MarkDescendants(Literal root);
 
  // Expands greedily the given at most one until we get a maximum clique in
  // the underlying incompatibility graph. Note that there is no guarantee that
  // if this is called with any sub-clique of the result we will get the same
  // maximal clique.
  std::vector<Literal> ExpandAtMostOne(absl::Span<const Literal> at_most_one,
                                       int64_t max_num_explored_nodes);
 
  // Used by TransformIntoMaxCliques() and MergeAtMostOnes().
  std::vector<std::pair<int, int>> FilterAndSortAtMostOnes(
      absl::Span<std::vector<Literal>> at_most_ones);
 
  // Process all at most one constraints starting at or after base_index in
  // at_most_one_buffer_. This replace literal by their representative, remove
  // fixed literals and deal with duplicates. Return false iff the model is
  // UNSAT.
  //
  // If the final AMO size is smaller than the at_most_one_expansion_size
  // parameters, we fully expand it.
  ABSL_MUST_USE_RESULT bool CleanUpAndAddAtMostOnes(int base_index);
 
  // To be used in DCHECKs().
  bool InvariantsAreOk();
 
  // Return the at most one encoded at the given start.
  // Important: this is only valid until a new at_most one is added.
  absl::Span<const Literal> AtMostOne(int start) const;
 
  mutable StatsGroup stats_;
  TimeLimit* time_limit_;
  ModelRandomGenerator* random_;
  Trail* trail_;
  ClauseIdGenerator* clause_id_generator_;
  LratProofHandler* lrat_proof_handler_ = nullptr;
  LratEquivalenceHelper* lrat_helper_ = nullptr;
 
  // When problems do not have any implications or at_most_ones this allows to
  // reduce the number of work we do here. This will be set to true the first
  // time something is added.
  bool no_constraint_ever_added_ = true;
 
  // Binary reasons by trail_index. We need a deque because we kept pointers to
  // elements of this array and this can dynamically change size.
  std::deque<Literal> reasons_;
 
  // The binary clause IDs. Each key is sorted by variable index.
  absl::flat_hash_map<std::pair<Literal, Literal>, ClauseId> clause_id_;
  // Stores a list of clauses added to clause_id_ that are only needed due to
  // ChangeReason calls. Once we backtrack past the first literal in the clause
  std::vector<std::pair<Literal, Literal>> changed_reasons_on_trail_;
 
  // This is indexed by the Index() of a literal. Each entry stores two lists:
  //  - A list of literals that are implied if the index literal becomes true.
  //  - A set of offsets that point to the starts of AMO constraints in
  //    at_most_one_buffer_. When LiteralIndex is true, then all entry in the at
  //    most one constraint must be false except the one referring to
  //    LiteralIndex.
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, LiteralsOrOffsets>
      implications_and_amos_;
 
  // Used by RemoveDuplicatesAndFixedVariables() and NotifyPossibleDuplicate().
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool> might_have_dups_;
  std::vector<Literal> to_clean_;
 
  std::vector<Literal> at_most_one_buffer_;
  const int at_most_one_max_expansion_size_;
  int at_most_one_iterator_ = 0;
 
  // Invariant: implies_something_[l] should be true iff
  // implications_and_amos_[l] might be non-empty.
  //
  // For problems with a large number of variables and sparse implications_ or
  // at_most_ones_ entries, checking this is way faster during
  // MarkDescendants(). See for instance proteindesign122trx11p8.pb.gz.
  Bitset64<LiteralIndex> implies_something_;
 
  // Used by GenerateAtMostOnesWithLargeWeight().
  std::vector<std::vector<Literal>> tmp_cuts_;
 
  // Some stats.
  int64_t num_propagations_ = 0;
  int64_t num_inspections_ = 0;
  int64_t num_minimization_ = 0;
  int64_t num_literals_removed_ = 0;
  int64_t num_redundant_implications_ = 0;
  int64_t num_redundant_literals_ = 0;
  int64_t num_current_equivalences_ = 0;
 
  // Bitset used by MinimizeClause().
  //
  // TODO(user): use the same one as the one used in the classic minimization
  // because they are already initialized. Moreover they contains more
  // information?
  SparseBitset<LiteralIndex> is_marked_;
  SparseBitset<LiteralIndex> tmp_bitset_;
  SparseBitset<LiteralIndex> is_simplified_;
  std::vector<Literal> tmp_to_keep_;
 
  // Used by AppendImplicationChains() to avoid processing a unit clause several
  // times.
  SparseBitset<LiteralIndex> processed_unit_clauses_;
 
  // For each literal l marked by MarkDescendants(), the literal that directly
  // implies l. The root literal is implied by itself. Contains garbage for
  // literals which are not marked.
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, Literal> implied_by_;
 
  // Temporary stack used by MinimizeClauseWithReachability().
  std::vector<Literal> dfs_stack_;
 
  // Used to limit the work done by ComputeTransitiveReduction() and
  // TransformIntoMaxCliques().
  int64_t work_done_in_mark_descendants_ = 0;
  std::vector<Literal> bfs_stack_;
 
  // For clique cuts.
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, int> tmp_mapping_;
  WeightedBronKerboschBitsetAlgorithm bron_kerbosch_;
 
  // Used by ComputeTransitiveReduction() in case we abort early to maintain
  // the invariant checked by InvariantsAreOk(). Some of our algo
  // relies on this to be always true.
  std::vector<std::pair<Literal, Literal>> tmp_removed_;
 
  // Filled by DetectEquivalences().
  bool is_dag_ = false;
  std::vector<LiteralIndex> reverse_topological_order_;
  Bitset64<LiteralIndex> is_redundant_;
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, LiteralIndex> representative_of_;
 
  // For in-processing and removing variables.
  std::vector<Literal> direct_implications_;
  std::vector<Literal> direct_implications_of_negated_literal_;
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool> in_direct_implications_;
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool> is_removed_;
  util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, int> estimated_sizes_;
 
  // For RemoveFixedVariables().
  int num_processed_fixed_variables_ = 0;
 
  bool enable_sharing_ = true;
  std::function<void(Literal, Literal)> add_binary_callback_ = nullptr;
};
 
extern template std::vector<Literal>
BinaryImplicationGraph::ExpandAtMostOneWithWeight<true>(
    const absl::Span<const Literal> at_most_one,
    const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool>& can_be_included,
    const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, double>& expanded_lp_values);
 
extern template std::vector<Literal>
BinaryImplicationGraph::ExpandAtMostOneWithWeight<false>(
    const absl::Span<const Literal> at_most_one,
    const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, bool>& can_be_included,
    const util_intops::StrongVector<LiteralIndex, double>& expanded_lp_values);
 
}  // namespace sat
}  // namespace operations_research
 
#endif  // ORTOOLS_SAT_CLAUSE_H_